Buttermilk PieBeautiful Creatures which is set in South Carolina and of course it referred to various foods, one of which was buttermilk pie. I had never heard of it and of course became curious about what it might taste like. I did a quick online search for a recipe and saw that it really was quite simple. As you can see from the picture above it resembles a custard pie. Now imagine a lemon bar that is not so tart and you can now almost taste it's goodness.